Many homeowners seeking to solve their hard water problems turn to automatic water softeners as the ultimate solution. Others prefer portable exchange tank soft water delivery instead of owning their own soft water system. Which solution is best?
Well, to answer this question, you first need to understand a little about both water treatment options. Here, we’ll take a look at what automatic water softeners are as well as the pros and cons to owning them. Then, we’ll do the same for portable exchange tanks. Armed with this valuable information and working with a local water treatment specialist, you’ll then be prepared to make an informed decision for your own household.
What Are Automatic Water Softeners?
Homeowners with hard water are familiar with the telltale signs: limescale buildup on fixtures, clogged pipes, appliances that fail prematurely, water spots on dishes, and more. Water softeners effectively remove the calcium and magnesium minerals that make the water ‘hard’. This leaves you with soft water that’s easy on you and your home. Like other appliances, water softeners are usually professionally installed and maintained.
Pros and Cons of Automatic Water Softeners
Benefits of Automatic Water Softeners:
- Unlimited soft water supply – Since automatic water softeners regenerate on site, they’re always ready to produce soft water at a moment’s notice. That means you’ll have an endless supply of soft water, even if your water usage is higher one month vs. another.
- Added value – Since automatic water softeners are owned by the homeowner, they can add value to your home. Potential buyers will recognize the benefits of soft water on appliance life, plumbing, and other household fixtures.
- Proportional brining and regeneration – Some automatic water softeners, such as our Evolve line of water softeners, come outfitted with Water Efficient Technology (W.E.T.). This enables them to make the most efficient use of water and salt while keeping the system running at peak performance.
Disadvantages of Automatic Water Softeners:
- Local regulations – Some municipalities have banned salt-based water softeners due to environmental concerns with the elimination of salt brine into sewers and septic systems.
- Maintenance – Like any other major appliance, regular maintenance is required to keep automatic water softeners running smoothly and efficiently.
- Cost – The upfront cost of automatic water softeners is higher than rental of portable exchange tanks. However, the long-term cost may actually be cheaper, depending on how long the system is used.
What Are Portable Exchange Tanks?
Also referred to as soft water delivery service, portable exchange tanks are tanks full of softened water. These tanks are routinely delivered to your home on a predetermined schedule. The tanks are owned and maintained by the water treatment company that delivers them. Furthermore, no drain or electricity is required for the tanks to operate.
Pros and Cons of Portable Exchange Tanks
Benefits of Portable Exchange Tanks:
- Convenience – Soft water is routinely delivered to your home based on a schedule determined by your specific water usage requirements.
- Complies with local regulations – Some municipalities have bans against salt-based water softeners. Since they don’t drain into sewer or septic systems, portable exchange tanks allow you to enjoy the benefits of soft water while still adhering to local laws.
- Portability – As the name implies, portable exchange tanks can be moved from one place to another. This is ideal for people who are renting a home and want soft water without having to get landlord approval for installing a water softener.
Disadvantages of Portable Exchange Tanks:
- Limited supply of soft water – Tank delivery schedule is based upon your typical water usage and needs. This may not account for times when you use more water, such as when you have guests during the holidays. During times like these, you could run out of soft water.
- Value – Portable exchange tanks are rented and not owned by the homeowner. Therefore, you get the benefits of soft water but don’t add long-term value to your home.
Automatic Water Softeners vs. Portable Exchange Tanks: Which Soft Water System Is Best For YOUR Home?
As you can see, there are pros and cons to both automatic water softeners and portable exchange tanks. The system that’s best for YOU will meet your specific water usage and treatment needs while complying with any local laws and regulations. Ultimately, only you can decide which soft water system is best for your home and family. It’s important to work with a water treatment specialist, however, to explore the options available to you in your area.
High Quality Automatic Water Softeners From Conner Water Systems
At Conner Water Systems, we’re committed to helping you improve and maintain your home’s water quality. From water softeners and whole house filtration systems to specialty filters, drinking water systems, ultra-violet disinfection systems and more, our water treatment products offer an affordable, eco-friendly way to get high quality water.
We’ve been serving the Santa Cruz area for over 60 years. And, our expert staff, including two Master Water Specialists, is ready to help you find the best solution for YOUR home. Simply contact us today and see what our locally-owned, full-service water treatment company can do for YOU!
